
<!--Created using ACI XMLMap Translator version 2.0.0.0 using map file: "ACI.XMLMap.MISMO.v2.6errata" version 1.1.-->
<VALUATION_RESPONSE MISMOVersionID="2.6">
  <PARTIES>
    <APPRAISER _Name="Gabriel Oliverio, Sr" _CompanyName="P.S. &amp; D. Appraisals" _StreetAddress="467 Branchwood Dr, Winterville, NC 28590">
      <CONTACT_DETAIL _Name="Gabriel Oliverio, Sr">
        <CONTACT_POINT _Type="Phone" _Value="(703) 915-0969" />
        <CONTACT_POINT _Type="Email" _Value="goliverio5@gmail.com" />
      </CONTACT_DETAIL>
      <APPRAISER_LICENSE _Type="License" _Identifier="A8552" _State="NC" _ExpirationDate="06/30/2024" />
      <INSPECTION AppraisalInspectionPropertyType="Subject" InspectionDate="08/15/2023" />
    </APPRAISER>
    <SUPERVISOR _StreetAddress="467 Branchwood Dr, Winterville," _StreetAddress2="NC 28590" />
    <LENDER _StreetAddress="70 Batterson Park Rd., Farmington, CT" _UnparsedName="Bank of America" AppraisalFormsUnparsedAddress="70 Batterson Park Rd., Farmington, CT, 06032" _StreetAddress2="06032" />
    <BORROWER _UnparsedName="Patrick Gould &amp; Mary Borges" />
  </PARTIES>
  <PROPERTY _City="New Bern" _State="NC" _PostalCode="28560" _County="Craven" _StreetAddress="1811 Spencer Ave" _StreetAddress2="New Bern, NC 28560" _RightsType="FeeSimple">
    <_IDENTIFICATION AssessorsParcelIdentifier="8-024 -134" CensusTractIdentifier="9607.00" />
    <_LEGAL_DESCRIPTION _TextDescription="City/Muni/Twp:New Bern 612 Ghent 1811 Spencer" />
    <_OFF_SITE_IMPROVEMENT _Type="Street" _OwnershipType="Public" _ExistsIndicator="N" />
    <_OFF_SITE_IMPROVEMENT _Type="Street" _OwnershipType="Private" _ExistsIndicator="N" />
    <_OFF_SITE_IMPROVEMENT _Type="Alley" _OwnershipType="Public" _ExistsIndicator="N" />
    <_OFF_SITE_IMPROVEMENT _Type="Alley" _OwnershipType="Private" _ExistsIndicator="N" />
    <SITE _ZoningClassificationIdentifier="No Zoning" _ZoningClassificationDescription="No Zoning" HighestBestUseIndicator="Y" />
    <PROJECT>
      <_PER_UNIT_FEE _Amount="0" />
    </PROJECT>
    <NEIGHBORHOOD _PredominantOccupancyType="Owner" PropertyNeighborhoodLocationType="Suburban" _PropertyValueTrendType="Stable" />
    <LISTING_HISTORY ListedWithinPreviousYearDescription="flexMLS" ListedWithinPreviousYearIndicator="N" />
    <_OWNER _Name="Patrick A. Gould &amp; Mary L. Borges" />
  </PROPERTY>
  <VALUATION_METHODS>
    <SALES_COMPARISON _Comment="1-3: While consideration was given to each sale, Comp 1 was given greater weight. Comp 1 was a recent sale and it required the lowest gross adjustments. The most recent sales support the opinion of market value. 4-6: Comp 4 was provided to lend additional support to the opinion of value." _CurrentSalesAgreementAnalysisComment="The subject property has not transferred within 3 years of the effective date of the appraisal. The comparable sales have not transferred within a year of the date of sale of the comparable sale.">
      <OTHER_FEATURE PropertyFeatureSequenceIdentifier="1" PropertyFeatureName="Fireplace" />
      <OTHER_FEATURE PropertyFeatureSequenceIdentifier="2" PropertyFeatureName="Porch/Patio/Deck" />
      <COMPARABLE_SALE PropertySequenceIdentifier="0" DataSourceDescription="PublicRecflexMLS">
        <LOCATION PropertyStreetAddress="1811 Spencer Ave" PropertyStreetAddress2="New Bern, NC 28560" />
        <ROOM_ADJUSTMENT TotalRoomCount="8" TotalBedroomCount="2" TotalBathroomCount="1.1" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="Other" _TypeOtherDescription="Fireplace" _Description="1 Fireplace" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="Other" _TypeOtherDescription="Porch/Patio/Deck" _Description="ScP,2Pr" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="Other" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="Location" _Description="N;Res;GhentHist" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="SiteArea" _Description="7,405 sf" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="View" _Description="N;Res;" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="DesignStyle" _Description="DT1.5;Ranch" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="Quality" _Description="Q4" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="Age" _Description="91" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="Condition" _Description="C2" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="BasementArea" _Description="0sf" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="BasementFinish" _Description="0" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="FunctionalUtility" _Description="Average" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="HeatingCooling" _Description="FWA/CAC" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="GrossLivingArea" _Description="1,536" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="CarStorage" _Description="1ga1dw" />
        <PRIOR_SALES PropertySalesDate="09/29/2021" PropertySalesAmount="110,000" />
      </COMPARABLE_SALE>
      <COMPARABLE_SALE PropertySequenceIdentifier="1" SalePriceTotalAdjustmentNetPercent="3.5" SalesPriceTotalAdjustmentGrossPercent="5.6" AdjustedSalesPriceAmount="341,500" SalePriceTotalAdjustmentAmount="11,500" SalesPriceTotalAdjustmentPositiveIndicator="Y" SalesPricePerGrossLivingAreaAmount="205.99" PropertySalesAmount="330,000" DataSourceDescription="flexMLS#100375033">
        <LOCATION PropertyStreetAddress="1421 Spencer Ave" PropertyStreetAddress2="New Bern, NC 28560" ProximityToSubjectDescription="0.44 miles E" />
        <ROOM_ADJUSTMENT TotalRoomCount="7" TotalBedroomCount="3" TotalBathroomCount="2.0" RoomAdjustmentAmount="-3,500" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="SalesConcessions" _Description="Cash/0" _Amount="0" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="DateOfSale" _Description="04/20/2023" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="Location" _Description="N;Res;GhentHist" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="SiteArea" _Description="7,405 sf" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="View" _Description="N;Res;" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="DesignStyle" _Description="DT2;Trad" _Amount="0" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="Quality" _Description="Q4" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="Age" _Description="103" _Amount="0" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="Condition" _Description="C3" _Amount="+10,000" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="BasementArea" _Description="0sf" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="BasementFinish" _Description="0" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="FunctionalUtility" _Description="Average" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="HeatingCooling" _Description="FWA/CAC" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="GrossLivingArea" _Description="1,602" _Amount="0" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="CarStorage" _Description="1dw" _Amount="+5,000" />
        <OTHER_FEATURE_ADJUSTMENT PropertyFeatureSequenceIdentifier="1" PropertyFeatureDescription="1 Fireplace" />
        <OTHER_FEATURE_ADJUSTMENT PropertyFeatureSequenceIdentifier="2" PropertyFeatureDescription="ScP,Pr,Fnc" PropertyFeatureAdjustmentAmount="0" />
      </COMPARABLE_SALE>
      <COMPARABLE_SALE PropertySequenceIdentifier="2" SalePriceTotalAdjustmentNetPercent="7.8" SalesPriceTotalAdjustmentGrossPercent="19.4" AdjustedSalesPriceAmount="318,000" SalePriceTotalAdjustmentAmount="-27,000" SalesPriceTotalAdjustmentPositiveIndicator="N" SalesPricePerGrossLivingAreaAmount="153.95" PropertySalesAmount="345,000" DataSourceDescription="flexMLS#100315896">
        <LOCATION PropertyStreetAddress="1511 Rhem Ave" PropertyStreetAddress2="New Bern, NC 28560" ProximityToSubjectDescription="0.37 miles E" />
        <ROOM_ADJUSTMENT TotalRoomCount="7" TotalBedroomCount="3" TotalBathroomCount="2.1" RoomAdjustmentAmount="-7,000" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="SalesConcessions" _Description="Conv/0" _Amount="0" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="DateOfSale" _Description="04/14/2022" _Amount="0" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="Location" _Description="N;Res;GhentHist" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="SiteArea" _Description="7,405 sf" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="View" _Description="N;Res;" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="DesignStyle" _Description="DT1.5;Ranch" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="Quality" _Description="Q4" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="Age" _Description="93" _Amount="0" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="Condition" _Description="C3" _Amount="+10,000" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="BasementArea" _Description="0sf" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="BasementFinish" _Description="0" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="FunctionalUtility" _Description="Average" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="HeatingCooling" _Description="FWA/CAC" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="GrossLivingArea" _Description="2,241" _Amount="-35,000" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="CarStorage" _Description="2ga2dw" _Amount="-5,000" />
        <OTHER_FEATURE_ADJUSTMENT PropertyFeatureSequenceIdentifier="1" PropertyFeatureDescription="1 Fireplace" />
        <OTHER_FEATURE_ADJUSTMENT PropertyFeatureSequenceIdentifier="2" PropertyFeatureDescription="Pr,Fnc" PropertyFeatureAdjustmentAmount="10000" />
      </COMPARABLE_SALE>
      <COMPARABLE_SALE PropertySequenceIdentifier="3" SalePriceTotalAdjustmentNetPercent="11.5" SalesPriceTotalAdjustmentGrossPercent="11.5" AdjustedSalesPriceAmount="295,500" SalePriceTotalAdjustmentAmount="30,500" SalesPriceTotalAdjustmentPositiveIndicator="Y" SalesPricePerGrossLivingAreaAmount="197.17" PropertySalesAmount="265,000" DataSourceDescription="flexMLS#100353875">
        <LOCATION PropertyStreetAddress="1809 Spencer Ave" PropertyStreetAddress2="New Bern, NC 28560" ProximityToSubjectDescription="0.01 miles E" />
        <ROOM_ADJUSTMENT TotalRoomCount="6" TotalBedroomCount="3" TotalBathroomCount="1.0" RoomAdjustmentAmount="+3,500" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="SalesConcessions" _Description="Conv/0" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="DateOfSale" _Description="01/05/2023" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="Location" _Description="N;Res;GhentHist" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="SiteArea" _Description="7,405 sf" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="View" _Description="N;Res;" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="DesignStyle" _Description="DT1;Ranch" _Amount="0" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="Quality" _Description="Q4" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="Age" _Description="95" _Amount="0" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="Condition" _Description="C4" _Amount="+15,000" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="BasementArea" _Description="0sf" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="BasementFinish" _Description="0" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="FunctionalUtility" _Description="Average" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="HeatingCooling" _Description="FWA/CAC" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="GrossLivingArea" _Description="1,344" _Amount="+10,000" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="CarStorage" _Description="1crp1dw" _Amount="+2,000" />
        <OTHER_FEATURE_ADJUSTMENT PropertyFeatureSequenceIdentifier="1" PropertyFeatureDescription="1 Fireplace" />
        <OTHER_FEATURE_ADJUSTMENT PropertyFeatureSequenceIdentifier="2" PropertyFeatureDescription="Pr,OutB,Fnc" PropertyFeatureAdjustmentAmount="0" />
      </COMPARABLE_SALE>
      <COMPARABLE_SALE PropertySequenceIdentifier="4" SalePriceTotalAdjustmentNetPercent="6.8" SalesPriceTotalAdjustmentGrossPercent="14.6" AdjustedSalesPriceAmount="368,500" SalePriceTotalAdjustmentAmount="23,500" SalesPriceTotalAdjustmentPositiveIndicator="Y" SalesPricePerGrossLivingAreaAmount="287.50" PropertySalesAmount="345,000" DataSourceDescription="flexMLS#100377773">
        <LOCATION PropertyStreetAddress="515 Queen St" PropertyStreetAddress2="New Bern, NC 28560" ProximityToSubjectDescription="1.53 miles NE" />
        <ROOM_ADJUSTMENT TotalRoomCount="5" TotalBedroomCount="2" TotalBathroomCount="2.0" RoomAdjustmentAmount="-3,500" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="SalesConcessions" _Description="Cash/0" _Amount="0" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="DateOfSale" _Description="06/06/2023" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="Location" _Description="N;Res;NewBHist" _Amount="0" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="SiteArea" _Description="6,69 sf" _Amount="0" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="View" _Description="A;NC Railway;" _Amount="+5,000" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="DesignStyle" _Description="DT1.5;Ranch" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="Quality" _Description="Q4" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="Age" _Description="103" _Amount="0" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="Condition" _Description="C3" _Amount="+10,000" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="BasementArea" _Description="0sf" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="BasementFinish" _Description="0" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="FunctionalUtility" _Description="Average" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="HeatingCooling" _Description="FWA/CAC" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="GrossLivingArea" _Description="1,200" _Amount="+17,000" />
        <SALE_PRICE_ADJUSTMENT _Type="CarStorage" _Description="2dw" _Amount="+5,000" />
        <OTHER_FEATURE_ADJUSTMENT PropertyFeatureSequenceIdentifier="1" PropertyFeatureDescription="3 Fireplaces" PropertyFeatureAdjustmentAmount="-10000" />
        <OTHER_FEATURE_ADJUSTMENT PropertyFeatureSequenceIdentifier="2" PropertyFeatureDescription="ScP,2pr" />
      </COMPARABLE_SALE>
    </SALES_COMPARISON>
    <INCOME_ANALYSIS>
      <RESIDENTIAL_RENT_SCHEDULE>
        <RESIDENTIAL_RENTAL PropertySequenceIdentifier="0">
          <ROOM_ADJUSTMENT UnitSequenceIdentifier="1" />
        </RESIDENTIAL_RENTAL>
        <OTHER_FEATURE_ADJUSTMENT PropertyFeatureSequenceIdentifier="1" />
        <OTHER_FEATURE_ADJUSTMENT PropertyFeatureSequenceIdentifier="2" />
      </RESIDENTIAL_RENT_SCHEDULE>
      <MULTIFAMILY_RENT_SCHEDULE>
        <UNIT_RENT_SCHEDULE UnitSequenceIdentifier="1" />
      </MULTIFAMILY_RENT_SCHEDULE>
    </INCOME_ANALYSIS>
    <PRICE_FORECASTING>
      <COMPETITIVE_LISTINGS>
        <COMPARABLE_LISTING PropertySequenceIdentifier="0" />
      </COMPETITIVE_LISTINGS>
    </PRICE_FORECASTING>
  </VALUATION_METHODS>
  <VALUATION PropertyAppraisedValueAmount="341500" AppraisalEffectiveDate="08/15/2023" />
</VALUATION_RESPONSE>